Pack your appetite and hit the road on a delicious adventure across Wisconsin with the Prime Rib Trail! Created in partnership with Gather Wisconsin and the Wisconsin Beef Council, this flavorful trail features some of the state’s most beloved spots to enjoy a classic cut of beef: the Prime Rib.
Each stop was selected from fan-favorite nominations on the Gather Wisconsin and Wisconsin Beef Council social media pages. Whether you’re a supper club regular or a first-time Wisconsin Prime Rib explorer, this meaty road trip is sure to satisfy your cravings and celebrate the local flavor of beef.
1. Donny’s Glidden Lodge, Sturgeon Bay
Calling all classic Wisconsin supper club lovers! Donny’s Glidden Lodge in Sturgeon Bay is the place for you. Nestled alongside the shore of Lake Michigan, this Door County gem pairs a great steak with a spectacular view. From their robust menu to their top-of-the-line staff to a charming stone fireplace (perfect for an after-dinner cocktail), Donny’s Glidden Lodge is the perfect dinner while visiting Wisconsin’s peninsula.
2. Black Otter Supper Club, Hortonville
Since 1972, the Black Otter Supper Club in Hortonville has kept it classic. Family-run and proudly rooted in Wisconsin supper club tradition, it’s best known for one legendary menu item: the 160 oz. Extreme Cut Prime Rib. Yes, that’s 10 pounds of beef, and yes, people really order it.
3. Schwarz’s Supper Club, New Holstein
With over 65 years in the business, Schwarz’s Supper Club is a community staple with a big reputation. Schwarz’s goes through over 900 pounds of prime rib each and every week! Hand-cut to one inch thick and topped with their own blend of seasonings, prime rib is what Schwarz’s does best.
4. The Packing House, Milwaukee
Family-owned by the Wiken family since 1974, The Packing House in Milwaukee is one-of-a-kind. As a “scratch” kitchen, The Packing House is known for producing its own dressings, stocks, sauces, breading and soups. Get their famous prime rib dinner served every Wednesday, Saturday and Sunday.
5. Fredrick’s Supper Club, Milton
Known for a casual yet refined atmosphere, Fredrick’s Supper Club is a charming gem in downtown Milton. Fredrick’s is known for its 22-hour slow-roasted prime rib, and diners rave about its level of tenderness. This is a nostalgic, must-try, classic supper club that will leave you wanting more!
6. Village Bar Supper Club, Kieler
A true supper club experience awaits at the Village Bar Supper Club in Kieler. Known for an excellent menu and generous cocktails, this quaint supper club is recognized for the best prime rib in the Tri-State area (three times!) and delicious seafood. Menu items come with generous portion sizes so bring your appetite for this hidden gem along the trail!
7. The Del-Bar, Wisconsin Dells
Award-winning food and rich history greet you at the door of The Del-Bar in Wisconsin Dells. Three generations of the Wimmer family have made The Del-Bar a culinary tradition of the Dells area. It has been recognized with numerous awards from Madison Magazine’s Best of Madison and OpenTable, so make sure to add this prime rib to your must-try list!
8. Rockton Bar, La Farge
If you are looking for a place a little more off the beaten path, Rockton Bar in La Farge is the place for you. Family-owned and operated since 1969, Rockton Bar is one of the largest restaurants in the area. Prime rib is the Saturday special and Sunday’s special is its “Almost” World Famous Barbeque Chicken from April to October.
9. Re-Pete’s Saloon & Grill, Black River Falls
Re-Pete’s Saloon & Grill in Black River Falls carries on a name locals never let go of. The building was once home to Pete’s Keg-n-Kettle, run by Pete Olson for nearly two decades. Even after a new owner renamed it “Pour Paul’s,” the regulars kept calling it “Pete’s.” So when current owners, Jerel and Jen, stepped in to revive the vacant space, they honored that tradition with a clever nod to the past: Re-Pete’s.
Re-Pete’s blends local history with fresh energy, serving cold drinks, delicious prime rib and a sense of familiarity that’s hard to fake.
10. Chicken Chaser’s Bar & Grill, LLC, Fall Creek
Chicken Chaser’s Bar & Grill in Fall Creek earns a loyal following across Wisconsin in addition to its local regulars. Chicken Chaser’s has a classic small-town bar and grill vibe with big-flavor appeal – giving you all the flavor at a reasonably low price. Looking for a noteworthy side? Chicken Chaser’s is home to legendary potato salad with an original recipe that has been served for over 40 years!
11. Jake’s Supper Club, Menomonie
Everything about Jake’s Supper Club in Menomonie is premier. From its scratch kitchen to its Tainter Lake views, you’re sure to be in awe after a bite at Jake’s. This spot features your classic supper club fare and drinks, but the star of the show truly is their specialty prime rib, seasoned and slow-roasted to the utmost perfection.
12. Lehman’s Supper Club, Rice Lake
Lehman’s Supper Club in Rice Lake has been family-run for four generations. Since 1934, Lehman’s has served a robust menu that brings a sense of nostalgia to the Rice Lake area. No stranger to Wisconsin traditions, this supper club features a full service cocktail lounge that is perfect for catching Packers and Badgers games in the fall.
13. Pine Creek Pit Stop, Ashland
If you are an ATV, UTV or snowmobile enthusiast and find yourself in Wisconsin’s Northwoods, Pine Creek Pit Stop in Ashland is the perfect bite just off the trail. The feature nightly dinner specials from Wednesday to Saturday that include a soup and salad bar. Swing on in as you enjoy the beauty of Northern Wisconsin.
14. Pub ‘N Prime, Saint Germain
Is a tiki bar more your style? Look no further than Pub ‘N Prime in Saint Germain – a name that nods to its specialty prime rib. Featuring a year-round, heated outdoor tiki bar connected to the restaurant, this spot is the perfect blend of supper club, island and sports bar life. Diners rave about the soup and salad bar options as well as an extensive appetizer list.
15. Somo Lake Resort, Tomahawk
Truly a traveller’s destination, Somo Lake Resort in Tomahowk features a tavern, restaurant, cabins and campground all located on Somo Lake’s south side. This tavern has a delectable menu in a location that makes it feel like a true Northwoods getaway.
16. Loading Zone Eatery, Wausau
Loading Zone Eatery is a casual dining restaurant that has served the Wausau area for over 50 years. Located just outside of downtown Wausau, their menu has something for the whole family to enjoy. Diners note its cozy dining area and homemade cheesecakes!